The announcement of Shakti Dubey because the UPSC Civil Companies Examination 2024 topper was met with celebration throughout India, but it surely additionally sparked a recent debate on the extraordinary calls for of the examination, with a former IPS officer questioning the system’s lengthy preparation cycle.
Her journey to Rank 1 spanned six years and 5 makes an attempt, with Political Science and Worldwide Relations as her non-compulsory topic—a timeline that prompted former IPS officer Yashovardhan Jha Azad to boost considerations on social media.
“Congratulations to Shikha Dubey, rating first in UPSC end result. However 5 try means 6 years of toil—the most effective years of youth gone in teaching?… Our examination and interview fashion ought to change. We’re regulators at finest and for that, you want management, backbone, integrity and dedication all with widespread sense. Greatest to offer solely 2 probabilities with age restrict 25,” Azad wrote on X, tagging prime civil companies our bodies.
He added, “This obsession with UPSC is costing the nation big, using the youth wrongly for five to six years. Teaching institutes are laughing all the way in which to the financial institution.”
The submit drew sturdy and diversified reactions. One consumer responded, “Each subject calls for money and time to succeed… somebody from a humble background could not turn out to be a lawmaker, however with sheer arduous work, can turn out to be a civil servant.”
One other warned towards reforms that harm inclusivity: “If age restrict is imposed that elitists so want, it is gonna harm the poor essentially the most.”
A 3rd commenter added, “Who beneficial properties with extra makes an attempt? The teaching class. However the candidate, as soon as profitable, additionally wants correct honing, which the present syllabus and coaching could not assure.”
Regardless of the controversy, Dubey’s story continues to encourage. Her success additionally displays broader variety, among the many 1,009 candidates really useful for appointment, UPSC knowledge reveals illustration throughout Normal (335), EWS (109), OBC (318), SC (160), and ST (87) classes. A complete of 241 candidates are at the moment on the provisional record, with one end result nonetheless pending.
The ultimate stage of the 2024 UPSC course of, the interview spherical, was carried out for two,845 candidates and concluded in April. Initially, the fee introduced 1,056 vacancies, later increasing to 1,132 positions throughout the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS), and different Group A and B roles.
Candidates can entry the total end result and upcoming particulars on upsc.gov.in, the place marks might be revealed inside 15 days.
