Studying Time: 4 minutes
The clock is ticking on a proposed Pennsylvania legislation mandating that college districts shield the federally assured rights of homeless college students.
The invoice gained traction final yr after a Heart for Public Integrity investigation revealed that districts within the state locked college students out of college for weeks or months whereas investigating their households’ claims of homelessness.
The laws, at present into consideration within the Republican-controlled state Senate, would reverse a state legislation that enables faculties to bar from class any college students, together with homeless youngsters, throughout residency disputes.
Pennsylvania’s present practices are at odds with the McKinney-Vento Homeless Help Act. That federal legislation requires that college districts instantly enroll college students experiencing housing insecurity — earlier than, moderately than after, a residency investigation — and supply them with varied assist companies.
The state Home unanimously handed the invoice in November; the state Senate Schooling Committee did the identical in March.
Earlier than the laws can head to the complete Senate for consideration, the state Senate Appropriations Committee, led by Republican Sen. Scott Martin, should approve it. The legislative session ends in late November, giving lawmakers about six months to vote.
In a press release offered to Public Integrity, Martin’s spokesman, Jason Thompson, wrote: “As a former chair of the Senate Schooling Committee, and as somebody who labored with households experiencing homelessness throughout his years working within the juvenile justice system, Senator Martin understands and appreciates the significance of guaranteeing continuity of schooling, particularly for younger individuals rising up in tough circumstances.”
Reporting on scholar homelessness by Public Integrity and accomplice information organizations throughout the previous 18 months has revealed deep-rooted issues, from funding disparities to uneven scholar self-discipline.
The tales have make clear the plight of homeless college students and sparked adjustments in insurance policies and practices.
In December 2022, Congress elevated funding for homeless college students by 13%, a transfer that got here after a years-long push by advocates and a Public Integrity investigation the earlier month in partnership with The Seattle Instances, Road Sense Media and WAMU/DCist. However that’s a whole lot of tens of millions of {dollars} beneath the extent many members of Congress thought was mandatory.
Earlier than the price range vote, Democratic and Republican members of Congress informed Public Integrity that the federal authorities should do extra to make sure constant assist for homeless college students, among the many most susceptible youngsters served by public faculties.
In Washington state, lawmakers almost doubled Homeless Pupil Stability Program funding to $9 million in 2023.
That adopted reporting by Public Integrity and accomplice The Seattle Instances in regards to the scarce funding to assist these college students. With the rise, this system boosted funding for 17 districts and offered monetary help to a different 30-plus.
Investigations within the sequence additionally revealed that college students experiencing housing instability face self-discipline in faculties at charges greater than their housed friends.
In California, almost 6% of homeless college students had been suspended in comparison with roughly 3% of all different college students, a Public Integrity evaluation confirmed.
In Washington state, college students experiencing homelessness had been suspended and expelled at virtually 3 times the speed of their housed friends, The Seattle Instances reported in a 2022 article. Research in 5 different states have discovered comparable outcomes.
‘Deep-seated issues’
A Public Integrity evaluation of federal schooling knowledge suggests a whole lot of hundreds of kids entitled to rights reserved for homeless college students go unidentified by the varsity districts mandated to assist them. Identification is the important first step to offering that help.
The evaluation discovered that 2,400 districts didn’t report having any homeless college students regardless of ranges of monetary want that make these figures inconceivable.
And plenty of extra districts are possible undercounting the variety of homeless college students they do establish. In almost half of states, tallies of scholar homelessness bear no relationship with poverty, an indication of simply how inconsistent the identification of children with unstable housing might be.
“You actually dove into how there’s profound under-reporting for McKinney-Vento-eligible college students,” mentioned Paige Joki, an legal professional with the Pennsylvania-based Schooling Regulation Heart.
“What that ends in is people stating that there aren’t issues when, in actuality, there are actually deep-seated issues which can be under-explored. … College students are actually paying the value for that.”
Unhoused and Undercounted
Federal legislation requires that public faculties help homeless college students to assist break what may turn out to be an inescapable cycle of hardship. However most of the college students who want that support fall via the cracks.
In almost each state, homeless college students graduate at a lot decrease charges. And dropping out of highschool will increase their danger of housing instability later in life.
Whereas federal legislation urges faculties to assist homeless college students, some districts in Pennsylvania and different states, similar to Maryland and Missouri, suspect residency fraud and launch investigations when households say they don’t have a everlasting house, tales by Public Integrity and reporting companions The Midwest Newsroom and St. Louis Public Radio revealed.
The instances typically contain college students who say they’re “doubled up” — the federal time period for sharing a house with buddies or relations due to financial hardship or lack of housing. These youngsters are thought-about homeless below McKinney-Vento.
The legislation mandates that faculties assist them by eradicating obstacles to these college students’ schooling, arranging transportation to highschool, waiving usually required paperwork and referring households to well being care and housing companies.
Public Integrity’s assessment of dispute data and inside emails from the Pennsylvania Division of Schooling, carried out as a part of our investigation, suggests the drawback is prevalent in suburban Philadelphia faculties, the place many conflicts occurred. These disputes typically end in extended scholar absences, inflicting important disruptions to their schooling.
Democratic State Rep. Jeanne McNeill, the sponsor of Pennsylvania Home Invoice 663, launched the laws after a faculty system within the southeastern Pennsylvania space she represents barred a scholar from attending class and receiving particular schooling companies throughout a residency dispute.
The Schooling Regulation Heart, which represents households in such disputes, advocated for the invoice throughout a state listening to on scholar homelessness final yr.
“These disputes might be fairly prolonged, and that ends in college students being denied the instruction time that they’re legally entitled to,” Joki mentioned in an interview with Public Integrity. “Schooling is a basic proper in Pennsylvania, and this invoice is a mandatory step to make sure college students aren’t being disadvantaged of this proper.”
