Keep knowledgeable with free updates
Merely signal as much as the Renewable vitality myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.
The author, a former US Treasury secretary, chairs the Paulson Institute
Probably the most pressing and under-appreciated vitality challenges dealing with the US is the bogus intelligence race with China. America is within the lead, however Beijing is investing closely to shut the hole. The query for Washington is: can the US keep forward with out a nationwide vitality technique to energy it?
The vitality panorama has modified dramatically lately. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine reshaped it in a single day. Costs soared and governments scrambled to scale back reliance on Russian gasoline. Vitality safety grew to become paramount. As Europe and different areas that aren’t vitality impartial search to handle these vulnerabilities, they’re more and more seeking to photo voltaic and wind to scale back fossil gasoline dependence.
China is forging forward, pairing long-term industrial technique with huge funding in each AI infrastructure and the vitality to help it. Its data-centre market is predicted to develop by almost $275bn between 2025 and 2029. It invested extra in renewables in 2024 than the US, EU and UK mixed. Beijing’s clear ambition is to dominate the applied sciences of the long run, understanding that vitality coverage can be key.
In the meantime, within the US, as AI fashions grow to be extra complicated and are deployed at better scale and cloud energy grows, electrical energy demand is rising sooner than utilities can construct capability. Some information centres now devour as a lot energy as mid-sized cities. In Virginia, they consumed roughly a quarter of the state’s energy load in 2023. This has elevated concern over strains on the system and better residential payments, resulting in new laws and an efficient moratorium on constructing information centres within the state.
The US should develop and deploy a clear-eyed nationwide vitality technique that prioritises velocity, flexibility and cost-effectiveness. Since demand for electrical energy considerably exceeds provide, it is smart to think about clear electrical energy as an “addition” to present vitality provides. The truth is, almost all extra electrical energy within the US final yr got here from photo voltaic and wind — conventional vitality sources can’t meet the necessity.
Fuel can not fill the void within the quick or medium time period due to turbine shortages. Coal received’t clear up the issue as a result of decommissioned utilities can’t be ramped again up quick sufficient to satisfy pressing wants (and air air pollution harms well being). Growth of nuclear energy is an important a part of the answer, however the US lags years behind and China is way forward in growing cutting-edge nuclear energy.
Given America’s abundance of pure gasoline, many information centres will nonetheless depend on it however smarter, sooner fashions are rising. For instance, a hybrid mannequin that makes use of photo voltaic and battery storage or peaking gasoline backup in intervals of excessive demand is faster to scale up, due to tools order and meeting lead occasions, air permits and interconnection. These additionally require much less upfront funding, and “all-in prices” are akin to baseload gasoline.
This mannequin will not be with out dangers. A near-term shock to the photo voltaic or storage ecosystems would depart a giant gap simply as AI energy wants are hovering. With out present photo voltaic incentives, which have pushed vital onshoring to create a degree taking part in area with China, and with the US administration’s tariff regime, the all-in prices of the hybrid mannequin will rise. However sticking with gasoline could be to sacrifice velocity of growth and wager in opposition to the speedy decline of photo voltaic and battery storage prices, which fell roughly 20 per cent final yr and greater than 80 per cent over the previous decade.
The fitting reply isn’t to decide on one vitality supply over one other, however to create, rapidly, the circumstances for scaling up what works. This implies the low-tax, light-regulation surroundings that enabled the US renewable vitality increase in the course of the first Trump administration. We must also exempt applied sciences reminiscent of long-duration batteries from import tariffs, whereas doubling down on help for US-based options in utility-scale storage. As for the way utilities get well prices, we should encourage funding in applied sciences that deliver down vitality costs for all.
AI is a significant driver of electrical energy demand. But it surely additionally has the potential to unlock substantial provide features. We are able to’t afford to overlook this second. Extra capability, decrease prices and better vitality safety are inside our grasp.
The US nonetheless has constructed a bonus in vitality independence. The check is whether or not we are able to meet the vitality wants of the subsequent period of innovation. If that’s the case, we can be in a stronger place in AI than some other nation for many years to come back.
